by Iwazaru » Mon Feb 12, 2024 1:18 pm
Personally, I loved all four Team Silent games (I revisited SH4 some years ago and enjoyed it very much despite a thing or two that raised my brows), and I really liked Shattered Memories when I played it (and I wish Barlow had a chance to make a similar game instead of those indie FMV adventures he now makes). I did not consider other games to be that much "awful" as well - I thought Origins was ~decent as a fanfic, and even Homecoming had some positive qualities (kinda... but admittedly I never finished it as I dropped it after some point).
I was never much interested in Downpour though, it felt like Alan Wake spinoff or something like that. Instead, I honestly thought that Cry of Fear did a much better job of "silent hill inspired game" despite it being so much emo.
I hated the official movie though (mostly because they omitted the tragedy of Lisa, overall it was dumbed down popcorn release and lacked depth of game it was based on) and I never watched the trashy sequel of it. On the other hand, I still have warm feelings about an amateur made "No Escape" which was perhaps the most grimdark.
As for recent Silent Hill announcements/releases...
I think Silent Hill 2 Remake is just not needed at all, and I don't like what I see from trailers so far. Ascension is some questionable shit I would not touch. Short Letter seemed ~okay for what it is (perhaps? I don't want to watch video you've posted, at least not yet, so I can only take a guess), but people will obviously hate it for the Silent Hill name attached to it. Silent Hill F still looks promising to me as a potentially interesting horror game, despite of whether or not it would be a fit for Silent Hill name. Maybe because my most intense years of being in Silent Hill fandom were mid-2000s, I stopped caring about "legacy" long ago (hell, I'm even not offended by weird spinoff games for arcades/mobiles anymore). Thing is, I don't care about current fanbase either - those guys came after me and I never understood them so whatever (also because it was Russian fandom I was a part of, I just can't relate to modern Western SH fans at all - they are too alienating with stuff I don't resonate with). In 99% I don't bother to watch or read any Silent Hill related "content" like YouTube videos because it will only led to facepalm from me (whether it would be some crazy ass theory discussion or some biased attempt to do a series retrospective). Silent Hill is one of things I grew up with, and it really influenced me back in days, so it's just inside me and I'mnot in need of anything outside about it. You may say it's just an arrogance of "og fan" but thats how it is for me.
Silent Hill f is going to be shit with a big budget...
My initial impression was a horror adventure / visual novel similar to Spirit Hunter NG (whose graphic artist supposedly works on F) or Shin Hayarigami.
They still haven't released an actual in-game trailer, so it's a mystery for now. But you might be right with pessimistic anticipation, of course.
In any case, I want people to support Toyama and his new game, Slitterhead. It is not going to be a horror game like Silent Hill or Siren (and most likely it will be pretty rough and under-budgeted), but after watching
all the videos they've made (mostly talking about this or that with other cool people like Jinji Ito or Hideaki Itsuno), I can feel that they are perhaps one of few remaining creators I can really trust with their sincere vision. And it really makes me sad when 99% people on gaming news sites react so much on recent Konami's Silent Hill necro-announcements, but do not care about Toyama's attempt to make a new game aftery leaving Soyny. Well, gaymers as they are.
As for Bloober Team (who are doing SH2 Remake) - I never got interested in Medium (which was their attempt to make Silent Hill alike game), even though I was ~ok about Observer (maybe most nice thing they created, idk). For me, much more important horror games of the recent years were Alisa, Tormented Souls and Signalis. Alisa is like Resident Evil 1 homage, Signalis always felt like a Fear Effect mutation to me (kinda) and Tormented Souls had a significant influence from both RE and SH.
Personally, I loved all four Team Silent games (I revisited SH4 some years ago and enjoyed it very much despite a thing or two that raised my brows), and I really liked Shattered Memories when I played it (and I wish Barlow had a chance to make a similar game instead of those indie FMV adventures he now makes). I did not consider other games to be that much "awful" as well - I thought Origins was ~decent as a fanfic, and even Homecoming had some positive qualities (kinda... but admittedly I never finished it as I dropped it after some point).
I was never much interested in Downpour though, it felt like Alan Wake spinoff or something like that. Instead, I honestly thought that Cry of Fear did a much better job of "silent hill inspired game" despite it being so much emo.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cAsnr9Od3Zg
I hated the official movie though (mostly because they omitted the tragedy of Lisa, overall it was dumbed down popcorn release and lacked depth of game it was based on) and I never watched the trashy sequel of it. On the other hand, I still have warm feelings about an amateur made "No Escape" which was perhaps the most grimdark.
https://youtu.be/KFhCtzVaODw
https://youtu.be/oMw5D5wi_a0
As for recent Silent Hill announcements/releases...
I think Silent Hill 2 Remake is just not needed at all, and I don't like what I see from trailers so far. Ascension is some questionable shit I would not touch. Short Letter seemed ~okay for what it is (perhaps? I don't want to watch video you've posted, at least not yet, so I can only take a guess), but people will obviously hate it for the Silent Hill name attached to it. Silent Hill F still looks promising to me as a potentially interesting horror game, despite of whether or not it would be a fit for Silent Hill name. Maybe because my most intense years of being in Silent Hill fandom were mid-2000s, I stopped caring about "legacy" long ago (hell, I'm even not offended by weird spinoff games for arcades/mobiles anymore). Thing is, I don't care about current fanbase either - those guys came after me and I never understood them so whatever (also because it was Russian fandom I was a part of, I just can't relate to modern Western SH fans at all - they are too alienating with stuff I don't resonate with). In 99% I don't bother to watch or read any Silent Hill related "content" like YouTube videos because it will only led to facepalm from me (whether it would be some crazy ass theory discussion or some biased attempt to do a series retrospective). Silent Hill is one of things I grew up with, and it really influenced me back in days, so it's just inside me and I'mnot in need of anything outside about it. You may say it's just an arrogance of "og fan" but thats how it is for me.
[quote]Silent Hill f is going to be shit with a big budget...[/quote]
My initial impression was a horror adventure / visual novel similar to Spirit Hunter NG (whose graphic artist supposedly works on F) or Shin Hayarigami.
They still haven't released an actual in-game trailer, so it's a mystery for now. But you might be right with pessimistic anticipation, of course.
https://youtu.be/Mcc2sR4sb1U
In any case, I want people to support Toyama and his new game, Slitterhead. It is not going to be a horror game like Silent Hill or Siren (and most likely it will be pretty rough and under-budgeted), but after watching [url=https://www.youtube.com/c/BokehGameStudio/videos]all the videos they've made[/url] (mostly talking about this or that with other cool people like Jinji Ito or Hideaki Itsuno), I can feel that they are perhaps one of few remaining creators I can really trust with their sincere vision. And it really makes me sad when 99% people on gaming news sites react so much on recent Konami's Silent Hill necro-announcements, but do not care about Toyama's attempt to make a new game aftery leaving Soyny. Well, gaymers as they are.
As for Bloober Team (who are doing SH2 Remake) - I never got interested in Medium (which was their attempt to make Silent Hill alike game), even though I was ~ok about Observer (maybe most nice thing they created, idk). For me, much more important horror games of the recent years were Alisa, Tormented Souls and Signalis. Alisa is like Resident Evil 1 homage, Signalis always felt like a Fear Effect mutation to me (kinda) and Tormented Souls had a significant influence from both RE and SH.
https://youtu.be/JN4DmhYZbz0
https://youtu.be/WRj0TnUoCJc
https://youtu.be/xfi7ivjXD3Y